So for my first Top Five list I’ve chosen to do my Top Five Film Adaptations. For a book&film to make my list they both have to blow me away, sometimes film adaptations are so far removed from the book it’s almost unrecognisable (I’m thinking of PS I Love You in particular) but I prefer them to stay more true to the book. With that in mind, my list is below and I must stress this is in no particular order.
5) A Time to Kill by John Grisham. I felt this film was very true to the book, so much so that whenever I read the book now I can hear Matthew McConaughey and Samuel L Jackson speaking the words, which is rare for me.
4) Silence of the Lambs by Thomas Harris. I don’t think anyone easily forgets Anthony Hopkins’ sinister performance as Hannibal Lecter. Perfect casting all round.
3) Misery by Stephen King. Both the book and the film scare me still now. There are slight differences between the book and the film but not as many as some. The fear translates really well to the screen. Again, great casting in Kathy Bates, can’t imagine anyone suiting the role better.
2) Atonement by Ian McEwan. Film really does the story justice, great cast, although I’m not normally a fan of Keira Knightley, stays true to the story.
1) The Harry Potter Series by J. K. Rowling. I know it’s cheating a little choosing an entire series but I really do think that the Harry Potter films are one of the best examples of how to take books to the big screen. They stay very close to the books, yes I know they’ve taken bits out in places but they do only have a limited amount of time, and I’ve never come away feeling like characters that I thought I knew from the books were acting in unusual ways.
So that was my list, what did I miss that you would have included? I must admit I found it hard to stick to 5, once I started thinking about it I found so many more I would have loved to have included. Share your thoughts on my list or add your own list in the comments section.